Connecting in-house lawyers, government officials and private practitioners to address the most important issues of the industry

Toxics in Consumer Products

Tuesday, November 13, 2012

By Elisabeth DeLisle and Julie Taylor

Over the past several years, increasing concerns have been raised regarding the presence of chemicals in consumer products (e.g. lead in toys, flame retardants in electronics, phthalates in plastics).  It has been suggested that certain such chemicals may be associated with cancer, asthma, autism, birth defects, infertility, diabetes and other chronic and acute diseases. 

The Massachusetts legislature has been considering action to address these concerns.  The latest iteration of such legislation, Bill S. 2079, An Act for a competitive economy through safer alternatives to toxic chemicals (, was reported out of the Joint Committee on the Environment, Natural Resources and Agriculture last year and sent on to the Senate Committee on Ways and Means.  Bill S. 2079 would, among other things: require the listing and categorization of chemicals; provide for designation of two to four priority chemical substances per year; require that manufacturers notify the state of products or processes that use priority chemical substances; require research to determine whether feasible safer alternatives exist for priority chemical substances; and require MassDEP to develop chemical action plans, including plans for requiring the substitution of safer alternatives for priority chemical substances in designated priority chemical substance uses.  No further action has occurred on Bill S. 2079. 

Massachusetts is not alone in considering action to require the use of safer alternatives for toxics in consumer products.  For example, the public comment period only recently closed on regulations proposed by the California Department of Toxic Substances Control (DTSC) ( that would establish a process for identifying alternatives somewhat similar to that proposed in Bill S. 2079.  It is unclear when such regulations will be finalized.

While policymakers work, some companies appear to be making attempts to address consumer’s concerns.  For example, earlier this year Johnson & Johnson announced that it would remove certain potentially harmful chemicals from its line of consumer products by the end of 2015.  (See    


Contact Elisabeth DeLisle at or Julie Taylor at with any comments or questions.


Health Law Committees

  • Health Law Communications Committee
    This committee publishes information relevant to health law practitioners. If you are interested in an editorial position or publishing an article, please contact the Co-Chairs.

    Contact Information

    Thaddeus Alan Heuer

    Foley Hoag LLP

    (617) 832-1187

    Meghan M. Cosgrove

    Donoghue, Barrett & Singal, P.C.

    (617) 598-6700

    Jerome B. Tichner

    McDermott Will & Emery

    (617) 535-4000

    Colin J. Zick

    Foley Hoag LLP

    (617) 832-1275

  • Health Law Education Committee
    Help develop relevant and innovative educational sessions led by a diverse group of talented speakers who cover health law issues. This committee promotes and oversees the educational programs for the Health Law Section, including the monthly Brown Bag Lunch speaker series and several in-depth seminar programs.

    Contact Information

    Joel K. Goloskie

    Pannone Lopes Devereaux & West LLC

    (401) 824-5100

    Gary A. Rosenberg

    Verrill Dana LLP

    (617) 274-2846

    Jennifer Gallop

    Krokidas & Bluestein LLP

    (617) 482-7211

  • Health Law Membership Committee
    This committee aims to increase participation in the Section through outreach activities.

    Contact Information

    Christine G. Savage

    Choate Hall & Stewart LLP

    (617) 248-4084

    Leslie Joseph

    Mount Auburn Hospital

    (617) 499-5752

    Robin Amber Johnson

    The Health Law Group

    (617) 455-7331

  • Health Law Public Policy Committee
    The BBA is very active in legislative and regulatory changes. Health law attorneys are often asked to lend their expertise.

    Contact Information

    Edward J. Deangelo

    Commonwealth Health Insurance

    (617) 933-3091

    Erika Scibelli

  • Health Law Social Action Committee
    Take public service to a new level. Focusing on unique ways to engage members in the community, this committee is the proud publisher of the Children's Mental Health Guide and oversees other initiatives.

    Contact Information

    Michael David Beauvais

    Ropes & Gray LLP

    (617) 951-7601

    Catherine Annas

    Beth Israel Deaconess Medical Center

    (617) 784-0147

  • Steering Committee
    The leadership committee of the Section organizes programs and discusses policy. To inquire about opportunities, please contact the Section Co-Chairs.